CASE STUDY

They hired for innovation.Progress still stalled.

A growing blockchain consultancy was bringing in highly skilled talent, but innovation initiatives kept losing momentum. The 4C Diagnostic revealed a gap between how newer and longer-serving employees experienced the same workplace.

Blockchain consultancy25 employee responses

THE CHALLENGE

The company came to us for communication training.

Despite investing in experienced, high-calibre recruits, the consultancy was struggling to turn ideas into sustained progress. Initiatives started with energy, then slowed or stalled between teams.

Leadership initially saw communication as the area to improve and approached Synthosys about a workshop. The 4C Diagnostic confirmed that communication needed attention. It also revealed a wider difference in how people experienced the organisation.

We have been putting time and resources into new initiatives, but they don’t get off the ground.

From the initial client discussion

WHAT THE 4C REVEALED

Innovation was not being experienced in the same way.

In the largest group, innovation was associated more with structure and control than with experimentation. Control is not a problem in itself. But if people feel they need permission before challenging ideas or trying new approaches, innovation can slow. The diagnostic showed why this was worth investigating.

DOMINANT INNOVATION PROFILE
60%

15 of the 25 respondents experienced innovation most strongly through Control.

Dominant culture orientation for innovation
Control 60%Connect 32%Compete 8%

These are groups with a dominant cultural orientation, not scores for how innovative employees are.

The split was also visible by role: senior leaders leaned towards Compete when describing innovation, while entry-level and technical roles leaned towards Control. Different groups were working with different assumptions about what innovation involved.

THE DEFINING DISCOVERY

Same company. Two very different experiences.

Information sharing revealed the clearest difference. Employees who had been at the company for less than five years leaned towards Control. Those who had been there for five years or more leaned towards Create.

How information sharing was experienced

4C culture quadrant · By length of service

Information-sharing culture by employee tenure Five tenure groups, reproduced from the 4C report's culture quadrant. Under one year, one to three years, and three to five years are all above the centre line towards Control. Five to ten years and over ten years are below it towards Create. Bubble size denotes group sample size: 10, 8, 4, 1 and 2 respectively. CONTROLCREATE COMPETECONNECT Information sharing by tenure, mobile view Under five years groups lie towards Control, while the two groups with longer tenure lie towards Create. Group sizes are given in the list below. CONTROLCREATECOMPETECONNECT
  • Under 1 year10 respondents · 40%
  • 1 to 3 years8 respondents · 32%
  • 3 to 5 years4 respondents · 16%
  • 5 to 10 years1 respondent · 4%
  • Over 10 years2 respondents · 8%
Bubble size reflects the number of respondents in each tenure group. Position follows the original 4C quadrant: towards Control at the top, Create at the bottom, Compete at the left and Connect at the right.

THE PERCEPTION GAP

Newer employees saw more structure. Employees who had been there longer saw more flexibility.

All three groups with less than five years at the company appeared on the Control side of the chart. Both groups with five years or more appeared on the Create side.

One possible explanation is that experienced colleagues have learnt informal ways to find and share information, while newer employees experience a more structured approach. The findings do not tell us why the gap exists.

WHAT TO INVESTIGATE

What are new starters experiencing during onboarding, or bringing from previous workplaces, that might explain this gap?

Only three of the 25 respondents had been at the company for five years or more. This is a pattern to investigate, not proof that onboarding caused it.

TEAM DYNAMICS

Senior leaders saw communication more negatively.

Communication scored below 40% across all four team dynamics overall. Senior leaders rated it especially low on several measures. That contrast mattered because communication training was the reason they had approached us.

Communication by role

Perception scores across the four team dynamics

Senior management / executives (2)Other employees (23, estimated)
Consolidation ~34%
Consistency ~36%
Clarity ~36%
Collaboration ~33%
Figures for other employees are approximate, calculated by excluding the two senior leaders from the 25-person overall averages. Some executive values are estimated from the original role chart, so the comparison shows the pattern rather than exact subgroup scores.

Communication needed attention. But the picture was not the same for everyone.

The leaders were right to raise communication as a concern. Yet they experienced it more negatively than other employees, particularly around shared understanding and working together.

That raised a useful question: why did senior leaders see communication differently from the people around them?

ALL FOUR

organisation-wide communication dynamics were below 40%

FROM EVIDENCE TO ACTION

The recommendation was to look inside the system.

We recommended investigating why new employees experienced more Control when leaders wanted people to contribute ideas and work flexibly. Was that perception shaped by habits brought from previous workplaces, or by what people encountered when joining this company?

01

Onboarding

What messages do new starters receive about questioning decisions, sharing information and trying new ideas?

02

The first few months

Are everyday processes and leadership responses encouraging initiative, or suggesting that people should wait for direction?

03

Leadership communication

Why do senior leaders rate communication more negatively, and where might understanding be breaking down?

THE VALUE OF THE DIAGNOSIS

Better talent was not the missing answer.

The company initially asked for communication training. The 4C revealed a more specific problem: different people experienced information sharing, innovation and communication in different ways. That gave leadership a clearer place to start, with onboarding and the employee experience.