CASE STUDY

Strong relationships.Weak follow-through.

People described loyalty and belonging. Yet teams worked in silos, ownership was unclear and decisions repeatedly returned to senior leaders.

Insurance sector156 employee responses

Two independent approaches.
Similar findings.

The consultant studied everyday working practices through interviews, workshops and observation. Separately, the 4C measured employees' experiences of culture and teamwork. Only afterwards were the findings compared.

The consultant observed

  • Silos affecting how teams worked together
  • Unclear responsibility and ownership
  • Decisions repeatedly returning to senior leaders

Interviews, workshops and observation

The 4C revealed

  • Uneven collaboration and information sharing
  • Low accountability scores across all four dimensions
  • Weaknesses in clarity, consistency and follow-through

Independent, organisation-wide assessment

Different methods. Converging evidence. The 4C independently measured the problems the consultant observed and revealed how people experienced them across the organisation.

Belonging was present.
Execution was less consistent.

The 4C made the gap between organisational culture and everyday teamwork visible.

Culture shape

Relational strength

Control (30%) and Connect (26%) were the two most prominent culture orientations. The report also found 42% of responses in the Control-Connect area, showing a structured culture supported by relationships.

Where teamwork struggled

Across the organisation, the four team-dynamics scores pointed to difficulties with shared direction, dependable follow-through, clear expectations and collaboration. These were not simply isolated concerns about one trait.

The averages weren't
the whole story.

Three findings show how the 4C moves beyond an average score to reveal what people experience and where they differ.

Accountability was weak across all four dimensions.

For the Accountability trait, the 4C found low scores for shared commitment, reliability, clarity and collaboration. The concern was not limited to one aspect of teamwork.

What this raises: Were responsibilities and decisions clear enough for people to follow through?

Where leaders needed
to look next.

Clearer evidence helped identify concrete questions to investigate rather than launching another broad culture initiative.

Decision ownership

Who could make decisions, and who was responsible for following them through?

Information flow

Was information creating shared understanding or simply being passed along?

Innovation across levels

Why did directors experience innovation differently from other roles?

The 4C showed leaders where to look next.

The 4C independently identified the organisational problems observed by the consultant, measured their reach and revealed important differences between groups. Leaders gained a clearer, more detailed picture of where to focus.

Back to all case studies